The pizza itself is heavenly. We got the gluten free option but were shocked at the size of the pizza. We are accustomed to GF being smaller but this was a personal sized pizza. We order two pizzas for three adults (usual for us) but this was not enough food. The worst part is that it cost $56 for two tiny pizzas. While GF is usually pricier too, the combination of size and price was a major disappointment. Pizza, vibe and service are all great but way overpriced and under served with portion.

Idyllwild pizza has come through again, as per our usual we got the Taqhuitz Supreme large and since there is only 2 of us we get to huge dinners out of it with leftovers. A win-win whenever we head up to Idyllwild

Stopped here for some pizza to go. Not too busy on a Monday night. Fast and helpful service! Hurried home to have our delicious pizza. Didn't know if a large was too much pizza for us but it was too good to save for later. Crust is perfect and not crunchy or too thick. Great flavor on the toppings! Would definitely come here again!

PIZZZA. Always good. Worth the wait (be prepared) I also enjoy their salads and chocolate chip cookies. While waiting you can enjoy some great classic pinball machines or have a cold beer.

Was checking out a wedding venue nearby and the fiancé and I decided to stop by before our trip back down the mountain. We ordered the cheesy garlic bread sticks and just a medium pepperoni pizza and when they came out we weren't super excited for them as they looked pretty average, but man the breadsticks were surprisingly good vs how they looked! The pizza was decent enough and their ranch/marinara was really good. A little pricey for what everything is, but that's expected in a small mountain town. Service was quick, friendly, and welcoming so overall we wouldn't mind coming back the next time we're up!

We got delivery from Bear Necessities while we were staying there. We got a lot of pizza and it did the trick. The spicy pizza is actually very spicy!!! The cheese, pineapple and pepperoni were good. I feel like the crust was a little bland but overall, how can you not like pizza? They also have a variety of things to order from besides pizza. I also drove by the place and it looks cute! It looked like they had outdoor seating too.

Went to Idyllwild Brewpub last week, Tuesday 10/24. Found out they were closed for lunch. Tuesdays in Idyllwild are a challenge. Idyllwild Pizza shares the same parking lot. I'm not a pizza fan; however, these nice folks dining al fresco told me there are other options on the menu. Entered and looked at the menu board. Yup - plenty of options. STUFFED RED PEPPER _ Mozzarella, Feta, Italian Sausage, Mushroom, Onion, Fresh Herbs. $15. Turns out I picked a 5-star winner. It took a long time to get my lunch, realized they were making this red pepper from scratch. No big deal as I love freshly prepared food and am more than willing to wait. It was delicious. Seasoning was spot on. It was huge, enough for lunch and dinner. It came out sizzling hot with a perfect red pepper roasted and holding things together. Honestly, I never expected anything this good. Reality is I will definitely be returning. Service was satisfactory. 5-stars because this was an amazing entree. They have it on the menu board as an appetizer; however, it is enough to feed two adults. Highly recommend.

Locals Favorite ! Idyllwild Pizza is a family-owned and operated pizzeria that has been serving up delicious pies made with fresh ingredients and homemade dough for over two decades. Originally located in a small building on North Circle Drive, the pizzeria quickly gained popularity among locals and visitors alike. In 2004, the owners moved the restaurant to its current location on Highway 243, which allowed for a larger dining area and a more prominent storefront. Idyllwild Pizza has become a gathering place for friends and family to enjoy a meal together in a casual, welcoming atmosphere. In addition to pizza, the menu features a variety of sandwiches, salads, and appetizers, as well as beer and wine. The restaurant is committed to using fresh, high-quality ingredients, including locally-sourced produce and premium meats and cheeses. The dough is made from scratch daily, and the sauce is made with San Marzano tomatoes. Idyllwild Pizza faced a devastating fire in 2018 that forced the restaurant to close for several months, the owners rebuilt and reopened with the support of the community. The history of Idyllwild Pizza is a testament to the power of community and the value of quality, homemade food. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to this beloved pizzeria is a must-do when in Idyllwild. Just step inside this cafe/restaurant and your taste buds will immediately water !